Best Vanilla Extract for Coffee Reviews 2022

KitchenMeg is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here.

It may sound surprising, but it is very accurate that you can use the best vanilla extract for coffee. Vanilla is a very popular ingredient that is primarily used in making different hot and cold desserts. 

In fact, you don’t have to add sugar or creamer to sweeten your coffee. Instead, you can use vanilla extract to enhance your coffee. It is a healthy alternative for you significantly if you are cutting down your daily calorie intake. 

In case you are an avid hot drinks lover. Then your taste buds will surely appreciate the rich taste of vanilla flavoring in your everyday coffee. All you need is a few drops of pure vanilla extract to enhance the flavor of your cup of coffee. 

Also, you can even use almond extract along with vanilla flavoring to add some oomph to your cup of coffee. However, the different options of vanilla extract available in the market can surely leave you confused. 

So, if you are looking for a vanilla extract to add to your cup of coffee. Then you have come to the right place. As I have selected the best vanilla extracts that will take your daily fix of coffee to the next level.

Read More: Can You Put Vanilla Extract in Coffee | Complete Guide 2021

1. Nielsen Massey Madagascar bourbon pure vanilla extract 

Madagascar bourbon vanilla beans are best known for their premium vanilla flavor. However, the Nielsen Massey Madagascar bourbon pure vanilla extract is one of the best extracts you can use in desserts. 

It has a sweet flavor with floral notes that shines through any desserts and for making coffee. The Nielsen Massey Madagascar bourbon pure vanilla extract has a vibrant texture. It comes in different sizes that include 2, 4, 8, 32, and 128 ounces. 

This classic vanilla is more of an affordable option of extracts with a diverse flavor profile. It is made using cold extraction to make sure that the taste elements remain intact. 

This pure vanilla extract is non-GMO verified, kosher, gluten-free, and vegan. Different people with different dietary requirements can use this pure extract for making vanilla products. 

Pros
  • Rich and creamy texture with velvety after tones.
  • It is made using high-quality Madagascar vanilla beans.
  • Classic taste is available at a reasonable price.
Cons
  • It comes with added sugar.

Check Also: Best Espresso Machine Under 400

2. Mccormick pure vanilla extract 

Mccormick pure vanilla extract is one of the best quality extracts made using Madagascar vanilla. It is made with the infusion of water, ethanol, and vanilla beans. This extract is gluten-free, does not have corn syrup, and is non-GMO certified organic vanilla.

The best thing about McCormick pure vanilla extract is that it doesn’t contain artificial additives or sugars. It has the classic Madagascar taste with a balanced yet rich undertone and a hint of bourbon. 

Moreover, this natural pure vanilla extract is perfect for enhancing your coffee and most recipes.

Since this vanilla extract is sugar-free, you can also use it as a taste enhancer for making savory dishes. Besides, the easy to pour spout on the bottle makes it much more convenient to use. 

Pros
  • Premium quality vanilla flavor.
  • It doesn’t include any artificial elements.
  • Best value for money.
Cons
  • The taste is not very rich compared to other vanilla extracts.

3. Watkins All Natural Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla

Watkins All Natural is downright the best baking vanilla that you can get. It comes with the classic vanilla flavor that many avid bakers can vouch for. This extract gets made using organic vanilla beans to get the authentic vanilla flavoring. 

The rich and natural aromatic flavors of this extract are used not just for baking. But it works to enhance the taste of many vanilla products. This quality vanilla without any artificial elements and corn syrup is gluten-free. It makes it a perfect choice for people on vegan diets. 

It is an ideal pick for those people who wish to add a natural and good vanilla flavor to baked goods. You can also use this pure extract in coffee to enjoy the richness of vanilla. 

Pros
  • It contains all natural elements.
  • Available in value sizes.
  • Ideal for baking and nonbaking recipes.
Cons
  • It comes with a low concentration of vanilla beans.

Read More: 7 Best Espresso Machine Under 1500 – Buying Guide 2021

4. Blue Cattle Truck Trading Co. Pure Mexican Vanilla Extract 

Finding pure Mexican vanilla in an affordable price range is nearly impossible due to the limited options available. However, the Blue Cattle Truck Trading Co. Pure Mexican Vanilla Extract is undoubtedly a unique find. 

It uses organic Mexican vanilla beans to achieve the authentic vanilla taste that we all love. Compared to the other Mexican vanilla extracts, the Blue Cattle has a very subtle taste perfect for making desserts. 

Also, it is an ideal pick for those who want to add a slight vanilla taste to their coffee. This Mexican vanilla is made in Mexico and comes infused with 35 percent alcohol. 

It is gluten free and does not include additives like sugar or synthetic flavoring. The best thing you will surely love about this get Blue Cattle Mexican vanilla is its rich and flavorful taste and aroma. 

Pros
  • Genuine Mexican vanilla taste.
  • The pure extract does not include any additives.
  • Available in different quantities.
Cons
  • It contains corn syrup.
  • High price.

5. McCormick Culinary Clear Imitation Vanilla Extract

The McCormick Culinary Clear Imitation Vanilla Extract is just what you need to add a strong vanilla flavor. The best thing about this imitation extract is that it retains its flavor even at high temperatures. 

It is the reason why in the vanilla industry, imitation vanilla is ideal for commercial baking. Also, if you are not too keen on the vanilla color, I am sure you will love this clear imitation extract. 

Besides, it gets made using high quality ingredients to give a very balanced yet rich vanilla taste. The best thing about this imitation vanilla is that it comes at a very cheap price.

All you need is a single drop of imitation vanilla to enhance the taste of your standard cup of coffee. It works as a great replacement to the thick pure vanilla, and it is an ideal choice for those who bake frequently. 

Pros
  • Works best for bulk baking.
  • Versatile use.
  • It lacks the use of preservatives.
Cons
  • The clear color tends to turn yellow after some time.

 You Will Also Love:  Best Coffee Maker for Coffee Snobs to Buy in 2021

6. Simply Organic Vanilla Extract

As its name suggests, the Simply Organic Vanilla Extract is a pure and organic vanilla extract available in the market. 

The brand Simply Organic itself is famous for the use of certified organic items. This extract is no different. 

In addition, it is free from any artificial coloring, sweeteners, GMOs, or preservatives. Instead, the vanilla bean extractives come infused with organic alcohol and water only. 

It has the same authentic taste as Madagascar vanilla with sweet and floral flavor undertones. Not only does this vanilla extract taste good, but it will surely add a heavenly smell to your coffee.

Another great thing about it is that it uses vanilla seeds collected by small farmers in Madagascar. Hence, support small scale businesses as well.

Pros
  • Fully organic and pure vanilla extract.
  • Manufactured using environmentally friendly procedures.
  • Good value.
Cons
  • The aroma is considerably subtle.

7. Rodelle Gourmet Pure Vanilla Extract

The Rodelle Gourmet Pure Vanilla Extract is only made using three major ingredients. It comes with pure vanilla, water, and alcohol. There are no additional sugars or preservatives in this natural vanilla extract. 

Moreover, same as any other vanilla, it comes with a rich flavor undertone with a very sweet aroma. This gourmet extract is free from GMOs and gluten. 

It is also kosher certified and has a slightly sweet taste just like the traditional vanilla extract. 

Besides, this vanilla extract also contains hints of chocolate, caramel, cream, and oak aftertaste. It is undoubtedly one of the best vanilla extracts that you can use for baking and for making coffee. 

You can use this natural extract for enhancing both your sweet and savory food items. Another great thing about Rodelle is that it believes in sustainable farming procedures. 

It is the reason why it sources vanilla beans from Sahanala, a small region of Madagascar.

Pros
  • Chocolate and vanilla undertone.
  • Vanilla extract is vegan friendly.
  • Affordable price compared to pure vanilla extract.
Cons
  • Comes in a plastic bottle.

Latest Reviewed: Best Grind and Brew Coffee Maker

8. Heilala Pure Vanilla Flavor Extract

Heilala Pure Vanilla Flavor Extract is the next best vanilla extract on my list. This good vanilla extract is famous for its classic vanilla flavor that will leave your taste buds tantalized. 

It has a very smoky, creamy, yet slightly sweet vanilla flavor. But at the same time, having a super-rich texture of pure concentrated vanilla goodness.

Since this is a premium quality vanilla extract, only a little is enough to add vanilla flavor. A teaspoon of vanilla extract is equal to putting one vanilla bean in your food.

In short, Heilala has downright the best vanilla that will enhance both your sweet and savory food items. You can use it for making pancakes, cakes, hot chocolate, and coffee.

Pros
  • It has a long shelf life.
  • The pure extract is made with handpicked vanilla beans.
  • Sugar free and gluten free
Cons
  • Comparatively, it is a bit pricey.

9. Kirkland Signature Pure Vanilla

The Kirkland Signature Pure Vanilla is yet another pick of the best vanilla extracts that you can get. This vanilla extract is an ideal pick for those who love to add a genuine flavor of vanilla. 

It is an affordable option having the classic Madagascar vanilla flavor. This pure vanilla extract has a very floral yet rich texture with a caramel-like taste. 

Unlike other vanilla extracts, it is elementary and doesn’t have a complex flavor profile. Due to its affordable price, you can easily get this best vanilla extract without breaking the bank. 

Besides, the deep beautiful dark color of the extract is very similar to that of a vanilla bean. 

Not only does it taste good, but it also adds a slight vanilla coloring to your cooking items. 

All in all, this sure is the perfect vanilla extract that you can use for enhancing your desserts and drinks.

Pros
  • Affordable vanilla extract.
  • It doesn’t include corn syrup.
  • Rich vanilla bean flavor
Cons
  • It may contain some traces of sugar.

10. Nielsen-Massey Tahitian Vanilla Extract

This Nielsen-Massey Tahitian Vanilla Extract is different from the vanilla extract mentioned before. 

The vanilla bean used in this extract is cultivated from Tahiti. It is yet another region famous for its vanilla beans. 

It has a very different flavor from the Nielsen Massey Madagascar bourbon extract. Since it is made using Tahitian vanilla. It has a very floral and fruity flavor with hints of anise and cherry. 

This is just the best vanilla extract you need to add richness and depth with a complex flavor profile. It works to enhance the flavor of desserts, drinks, and many vanilla things. 

Another great thing about this vanilla extract is that it is gluten free, does not have any preservatives. This makes it an ideal choice for making vegan and kosher foods.

Pros
  • It doesn’t have corn syrup.
  • Floral and fruity flavor undertones.
  • Non GMO with a long shelf life.
Cons
  • It includes some added sugar.

Buying Guide – Important factors to consider when getting the Best Vanilla Extract

Vanilla plays an essential part in making most hot and cold desserts. Unfortunately, many of us think about it as just an ingredient that gives a vanilla flavor. 

But, in truth, vanilla extract is so much more than that. So, before buying vanilla extract, there are a few essential things that you need to look out for. 

Vanilla Beans Origins 

Vanilla is a very sensitive crop itself. It is the reason why there are not many places where vanilla beans are grown. Vanilla beans take about a year to develop. 

Another half-year is spent for the vanilla bean to mature and cure the same as any good wine. Some places are very popular for their vanilla bean.

Madagascar 

Vanilla beans grown in Madagascar take about eighty percent of the world’s vanilla bean production. These are commonly known as Madagascar bourbon vanilla beans. 

Bourbon is an island on the east of Madagascar. It is the place where the pure vanilla beans get cultivated from. 

The vanilla extract made using Madagascar vanilla beans has a rich, robust, and high quality vanilla flavor. This vanilla extract is used for making baking goods, different desserts, and also used for making coffee.

Mexico 

The ancient Totonacs and Aztec people originally cultivated Mexican vanilla beans. Mexican vanilla is not as common as Madagascar vanilla, but it is well known for its unique flavor. 

It comes with a very distant spicy and woody flavor that enhances the flavor of desserts and coffee. Besides, it also works well with different baking spices such as nutmeg, cinnamon, and clove. 

Tahiti 

Tahitian vanilla is famous for its unusual flavor. It has a very fruity and floral flavor undertone. However, due to its expensive price, it is not as commonly used as Madagascar vanilla.

But, the tropical flavor of Tahitian vanilla may likely be reduced when used in heavy baking recipes. 

To get the most flavor out of this particular vanilla, you can use it in hot and cold drinks. 

Other Tropical Regions

Though the following three regions are from where the most vanilla extracts come from. But, high-quality vanilla beans are also found in Indonesia and other tropical areas. 

The vanilla industry based in Indonesia also produces vast quantities of vanilla bean extractives. 

Traditionally, the vanilla pods are dried in the sun and take about a month to cure in the extraction process. 

Comparatively, the extraction process used in Indonesia is very different. In Indonesia, the vanilla beans are taken from the vanilla pods and dried over a fire. 

This process is much faster than the traditional one and adds a unique woody flavor to the coffee. 

Pure Vanilla Extracts Vs Imitation Vanilla Extracts

Pure natural vanilla extract is the most diverse type of vanilla extract that you can find. It gets made by infusing vanilla beans with 35 percent alcohol. 

This then undergoes an extraction process where it is heated for flavor extraction. The alcohol gradually evaporates as the vanilla beans are gradually heated. 

The downside of using this method is that vanilla beans tend to lose some flavor elements due to the heat. 

Therefore, for a diverse range of flavors of vanilla, the cold extraction process is used on the vanilla beans. Comparatively, the cold extraction process is more costly and takes a long time. 

Imitation vanilla extracts do not use vanilla beans. Instead, it is made using artificial flavors of the synthetically produced chemical vanillin. 

Though, vanillin contains a very similar chemical structure as pure vanilla. It lacks other flavors and elements present in pure vanilla extracts. 

The imitation vanilla comes in a clear liquid. It is also sometimes mixed with caramel color components to give the same feel as the natural extract.

Size 

Vanilla extracts come in different sizes. For example, you can get a 2-ounce bottle of up to a gallon of vanilla extracts. 

Small-sized bottles of vanilla extracts are ideal for home cooking, baking, or making coffee. These are available at a reasonable price range compared to larger-sized bottles. 

Ingredients 

In the vanilla flavor extraction process, the beans are infused with alcohol and water. Some extracts also come with a bit of added sugar and artificial flavoring. 

But the best vanilla extracts are those that come with little additives or no added sugar. 

Strength 

Vanilla extracts either come in double strength or single strength. By strength, it means the number of vanilla beans infused with water and alcohol. 

Double strength, as the name suggests, is much more concentrated and gets used commercially. At the same time, single strength vanilla is much more suited for home use or small baking projects.

Storage

The vanilla extract, when stored properly, doesn’t get damaged even for an extended period. It shows that vanilla extract has a long shelf life. 

It is due to the addition of water and alcohol that makes it easy to store vanilla in a cool place. Some people even tend to think the more aged the vanilla extract, the better it tastes. 

Must Check:  Best Espresso Machine Under 150

Frequently Asked Questions:

What type of vanilla is best for coffee? 

Any type of pure vanilla extract works as the best vanilla extract for coffee. 

Is it bad to put vanilla extract in coffee? 

Vanilla is a commonly used element used in many different types of food items. It is a safe element to use in coffee and doesn’t cause any adverse effects. 

How much vanilla extract should I put in my coffee?  

You just need to add a few teaspoons of vanilla extract to the pod of freshly brewed coffee. It helps to enhance and sweeten the flavor of your coffee without the use of added sugar.

Final Thoughts 

Vanilla extract is a thick concoction that gets infused with water and alcohol. It not only works to sweeten your coffee, but it also adds a rich vanilla flavor to your coffee. You can either use imitation vanilla or pure vanilla extract to add to your desserts, baked goods, or coffee. 

Since vanilla has a powerful flavor, it would be best if you put only a few drops into your coffee pot as it brews. 

You can find all the information relating to the best vanilla extract for coffee. It will indeed prove to be helpful to you in finding the one that works best for you.

Contrary to traditional belief, the use of vanilla extract is not just limited to baking items. The combination of coffee with vanilla adds richness and elevates the overall flavor of regular coffee. 

Leave a Comment